white-footed mouse, Credit: Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies
Share

“Survival of the fittest” Theory proved Wrong in a 26-Year Research

The mainstream education teaches that the animals in the world are evolved by the “Survival of the Fittest” principal and Darwinism is developed from it. However, a research on physical impaired white-footed mice that span 26 years shows that the survival doesn’t belong to the fittest along; actually, the seemingly unfitted can even thrive.

Researchers found that mice with missing or deformed limbs, tails or eyes persisted at a rate similar to their unimpaired counterparts. A new study in Proceedings of the Royal Society B assessed 26 years of monitoring data on wild populations of white-footed mice — representing more than 27,244 animals — and found that mice with missing or deformed limbs, tails or eyes persisted at a rate similar to their unimpaired counterparts. 

The bottom line: White-footed mice can survive and thrive, even with physical impairments.

white-footed mouse, Credit: Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies
white-footed mouse, Credit: Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies
The white-footed mouse, Peromyscus leucopus, is the subject of a new study.

Credit: Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies

Co-author Richard Ostfeld, a disease ecologist at the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies, said that the “results of our long-term study on wild white-footed mice do not support the long-held assumption, sometimes applied to vertebrates more broadly, that physical impairments reduce measures of fitness such as survival, movement and mass.

The U.S. National Science Foundation-supported research team analyzed data from a long-term mark-recapture program that Ostfeld initiated on Cary Institute’s Millbrook, New York, property. Small mammals were trapped at six plots in a deciduous forest dominated by oaks and maples. Catch-and-release trapping occurred every three to four weeks over two to three consecutive days between May and November using live traps baited with oats. 

Mice were given metal ear tags upon first capture, and data on sex, age, mass, ectoparasite load and location were recorded. In addition, the scientists took detailed notes about the physical features of each animal.

To assess the impact of physical impairments on the fitness of mice, notes from 1991 to 2016 were reviewed. Mice with the following impairments were included in the study: missing, partially missing, or broken tails; missing, partially missing, or broken/deformed limbs; and missing eyes or cataracts. Survival was estimated by persistence time on the plots.

Doug Levey, a program director in NSF added, “This study is both powerful — more than 27,000 wild mice over 26 years — and surprising. Until now, few ecologists would have said that impaired mice live as long as mice that are free of impairments.”


Reference: NSF. (2021, November 30). Physically impaired wild mice survive and thrive [Press release].